El Pitallito — Authentic Mexican Food
4.5120+ verified reviews

Washington Heights · Since 2024 · Delivery to 12 AM

Slow-Braised Birria. Hand-Pressed Tortillas. Real Mexico, Real Broadway.

3 birria tacos + consomé · $17. Al Pastor 3-pack · $13. Open daily, delivery until midnight.

Ask About Today's Especial del Día
Open Daily · 9 AM – 12 AMDelivery Daily until 12 AM3854 Broadway
Tortilla being toasted over open flame

Fire-toasted before plating. Every order.

Hecho a Mano · Made by Hand

A kitchen, not a factory.

"Every tortilla is pressed before service. Every consomé takes twelve hours. We don't cut corners — we don't know how."
Steven · General Manager

We opened on Broadway in 2024 because Washington Heights deserved real Mexican food. No fusion. No shortcuts. The recipes our grandmothers taught us — masa pressed by hand, salsas made every morning, birria slow-braised the way it is meant to be.

12h

Birria Braise

Daily

Tortillas Pressed

0

Shortcuts

Quesabirria with melted cheese pull and rich consomé

House consomé

Slow-braised fresh, every single day.

The Dish We’re Known For

Why people keep coming back for the birria

Beef braised slow until it falls apart, dipped in rich red consomé, with melted cheese on hand-pressed tortillas seared on the comal. Cilantro, onion, and a hot cup of consomé to dunk. Late-night comfort food, done the real way.

  • Slow-braised daily
  • Rich house consomé
  • Hand-pressed tortillas
  • Served piping hot

No Shortcuts · Sin Atajos

Straight from our kitchen

Every plate is made by hand, every day. Nothing frozen, nothing rushed.

Masa pressed by hand
01

Masa pressed by hand

Over open flame
02

Over open flame

Consomé, slow-simmered
03

Consomé, slow-simmered

Cut fresh, all day
04

Cut fresh, all day

Plated to order
05

Plated to order

Reviews · Reseñas

What Our Neighbors Say

Real reviews from Seamless, Grubhub, DoorDash & Uber Eats.

4.5120+ reviewsGrubhub · Seamless · DoorDash · Uber Eats
I order the chile rellenos and mole poblano almost every week. Never once disappoints.

Scott

SeamlessMole Poblano

It feels like having a Mexican neighbor that cooks for you.

Brehona

SeamlessComfort Food

Chorizo seasoned right. Al pastor tacos are exactly what you want from a real Mexican kitchen.

Chris

GrubhubTacos al Pastor

Hand-pressed tortillas. You can taste the difference — actually authentic.

Irma

SeamlessTortillas

Our Standard

When Something Goes Wrong, We Make It Right

When a customer received the wrong dish at end of service, our GM Steven re-cooked her meal and delivered it free the next evening. Real hospitality. Real accountability.

— Verified guest experience · Steven, General Manager

Order Direct

Skip the delivery-app markups

Better price

No delivery-app markup tacked on. What you see is what you pay.

Fresher food

Goes straight to our kitchen and gets made to order — no middleman.

Supports the block

Ordering direct backs a local kitchen, not a billion-dollar app.

Order in 30 Seconds

Pickup direct (best price), or DoorDash / Uber Eats / Grubhub / Seamless.

Delivery 9 AM – 12 AM · Dine-in & Pickup 9 AM – 12 AM

Severe allergy? Call us first — we take it seriously and will guide your order.

Visit · Visítanos

Come Eat With Us

Address

3854 Broadway, New York, NY 10032

Between 160 St & 161 St · Washington Heights

Hours

  • Mon9:00 AM – 12:00 AM
  • Tue9:00 AM – 12:00 AM
  • Wed9:00 AM – 12:00 AM
  • Thu9:00 AM – 12:00 AM
  • Fri9:00 AM – 12:00 AM
  • Sat9:00 AM – 12:00 AM
  • Sun9:00 AM – 12:00 AM